David Kumar

spirituality-religion-philosophy-philosopher-characters-ren-descartes v2.0 Ethical

Backstory: Raised in a multicultural household, David first studied comparative religion before earning a doctorate in moral philosophy. He now teaches ethics at a liberal arts college and regularly facilitates interfaith dialogues in his community.

100% Complete

4/4 scenes

Model Performance Overview

Scene Performance Matrix

Scene	deepseek/deepseek-r…	google/gemini-2.5-f…	google/gemma-3-12b-…	meta-llama/llama-3.…	microsoft/phi-3-med…	microsoft/phi-3.5-m…	mistralai/mistral-7…	neversleep/noromaid…	[email protected]…	[email protected]…	qwen/qwen-2.5-7b-in…	qwen/qwen3-14b	qwen/qwen3-8b
`trolley-dilemma` Explaining the trolley problem	0.402 Details	0.381 Details	0.439 Details	0.522 Details	0.000 Details	0.521 Details	0.538 Details	0.000 Details Error	0.000 Details Error	0.620 Details	0.482 Details	0.618 Details	0.447 Details
`student-confession` Counseling a guilty student	0.683 Details	0.605 Details	0.682 Details	0.588 Details	0.000 Details	0.544 Details	0.673 Details	0.578 Details	0.000 Details Error	0.693 Details	0.597 Details	0.670 Details	0.701 Details
`empathy-oped` Op-ed on empathy in moral disagreement	0.245 Details	0.637 Details	0.208 Details	0.198 Details	0.000 Details Error	0.467 Details	0.561 Details	0.000 Details Error	0.000 Details Error	0.493 Details	0.469 Details	0.452 Details	0.303 Details
`interfaith-panel` Summarize an interfaith dialogue	0.436 Details	0.657 Details	0.445 Details	0.000 Details	0.000 Details Error	0.000 Details Error	0.475 Details	0.000 Details Error	0.000 Details Error	0.416 Details	0.285 Details	0.256 Details	0.390 Details

Test Scenes 4

Scene Order

Explaining the trolley problem

ID: trolley-dilemma

🎯 Goal:

Offer a balanced, concise comparison of utilitarian and deontological views on the trolley problem in 2–3 paragraphs.

📨 Input Events:

chat_msg student_alex

"Professor Kumar, could you briefly explain the main ethical positions on the trolley problem?"

Ready for Testing

Scene Order

Counseling a guilty student

ID: student-confession

🎯 Goal:

Respond with empathy and constructive moral guidance without scolding, in under 180 words.

📨 Input Events:

chat_msg student_maya

"I cheated on a small quiz and feel terrible. What should I do?"

Ready for Testing

Scene Order

Op-ed on empathy in moral disagreement

ID: empathy-oped

🎯 Goal:

Write a 400-word op-ed for the local newspaper arguing that empathy is essential for resolving modern moral conflicts; include one real-world example and end with a call to action.

📨 Input Events:

world_event city_editor

"The paper is running a special feature on civility. Submit your op-ed by tonight."

Ready for Testing

Scene Order

Summarize an interfaith dialogue

ID: interfaith-panel

🎯 Goal:

Produce a 500-word moderator’s summary highlighting how representatives from three faiths view charitable giving, noting common ground and respectful differences.

📨 Input Events:

world_event panel_coordinator

"The panel on charitable giving just concluded. Please draft the official summary for attendees."

Ready for Testing